Card Present Chargebacks
"Impossible” disputes, specifically in the card present environment, have become a growing concern for merchants.
"Impossible" in this context refers to scenarios including dispute reasons like “Goods Not Received” for an in-store pickup or “Not as Described” for a sealed commodity good. These are examples of a systematic problem in the payment ecosystem despite the evolution of global card network dispute resolution frameworks.
These scenarios have led to consequences that are taking a toll on merchants and consumers alike, namely:

Root Cause Blindness
When chargebacks are miscoded, identifying the true root cause and implementing an appropriate remedy becomes significantly more difficult.

Customer Experience Erosion
Customers may lose trust in the merchant, leading to dissatisfaction and attrition.

Wrong Evidence, Wrong Outcomes
Misaligned reason codes lead to irrelevant evidence, unresolved disputes, higher financial losses, and strain on the payment ecosystem.

Merchant Disengagement
Merchants may lose confidence in the dispute process and become reluctant to pursue pre-arbitration or arbitration.
AI’s Impact on the Chargeback Process
As issuers increase their utilization and reliance on artificial intelligence, the cardholder’s dispute process may become more user friendly, but merchants are disproportionately incurring the losses.
How issuers choose to train their models will have a direct impact on the ease of consumers to file chargebacks, without an actual case to back it up. AI models trained to win a chargeback case could result in the model stopping at nothing to win.
Introducing an industry standard on training AI models to handle the chargeback process equitably for all parties involved could increase trust in the process.
Do all global card networks and issuers see the same card-present chargeback trends?
All global card networks and issuers do not see the same volume of card present chargebacks and likely first party fraud chargebacks.
In the first graph below, compared to the year prior Global Network 1 saw a decrease in overall card-present chargebacks with a slight increase in likely first party fraud chargebacks.
In the second graph, the non-top 5 issuers grew in their share of card-present chargebacks which is due to both an increase in number of issuers in the group and also a couple of non-top 5 issuers seeing a significant increase in card-present chargeback volume in July 2026 compared to the prior year.
Increase in Card-Present Chargebacks by Malaysian Bank
A BIN associated with a Malaysian bank saw a sudden increase in card-present chargebacks in the second quarter of 2026. The majority of these chargebacks were given dispute reason codes including "Goods Not Received" and "Goods Defective."
This seemingly random spike in chargebacks from a smaller issuer highlights concerns surrounding the wider payment ecosystem's need for for an improved dispute workflow and revealing they are not solely isolated to larger issuers.
Data as a Solution
While it’s easy to start pointing fingers, it would seem as though these types of chargebacks are a perfect storm of cardholder misinterpretation of the process, low-friction dispute processes from issuers, and limited data visibility from processors and networks.
An improved dispute workflow could lead to more fair outcomes for all parties involved but will require all parties to own their part.

Cardholder
- Submit accurate and truthful claims
- Provide relevant supporting documentation upfront
- Engage merchant before escalating to formal dispute where possible

Issuer
- Validate and classify disputes accurately
- Provide complete and structured data downstream
- Evolving automation logic
- Review before rejection and provide actionable feedback

Processor
- Transmit full, unfiltered dispute data
- Enable merchant participation in pre-arbitration
- Increase fee transparency; improve reporting; upgrade technology; strengthen network compliance

Card Network
Modernize rules adapting to evolving commerce
- Delivery Signatures
- IP Consistency Expectations
- T&C Acceptance Mechanics
- Photos/Product Use
- Scan & Go / Modern Checkout Gaps
A Global Perspective
Click the regions below to read more.

APAC

Europe
What Should Merchants Do Now?
Solving chargeback challenges necessarily requires collaboration across the ecosystem, making participation in industry working groups critical to driving meaningful change.
ISO 8583 Connection
DE 74: Reconciliation Data Primary
The seventy-fourth data element of ISO 8583 is Reconciliation Data Primary. This data element consists of twelve sub-elements including credits chargeback amount and debits chargeback amount.
Note: Reconciliation Data Primary has previously been located as data elements 105 and 106 in the 1993 version of the ISO 8583 standard and data elements 87 and 89 in the 1987 version.
Get Involved
Change only happens when people act. CMSPI and the MPL Council are working together to provide practical solutions to move the payments industry forward. Join one of our working groups to be a part of the conversation.
Working Group Interest Form
Loading...