BINs of Interest
It has been estimated there will be more than 30 million individual card programs by 2029, making six-digit BIN intelligence increasingly inadequate for payments optimization. The demand for a better BIN file has never been greater.
Part of the implicit contract with card networks, when operating under Honor All Cards/Issuers, is that there is an element of consistency in the acceptance experience for these cards and issuers.
Over the last decade or so, the advent of Financial Technology aimed at consumers and businesses has resulted in a pursuit for deposits. A combination of hardware and app stores that remove the need for physical banking locations, increasing trust of (or apathy towards) non-traditional bank entities holding funds, and growth in access to financial data more generally from the likes of Europe's PSD2 have created an environment ripe for growth.
In most corners of the globe, this innovation materializes as digital wallets, QR code-using apps, direct bank transfers reskinned, or 'Super Apps' combining lifestyle and finance.
In the United States, this is far from the case. The card-dominated market has led Fintechs to seek the most profitable and well-trodden path. One reason this path could be more attractive is due to the higher interchange on cards in the U.S. compared to other regulated markets globally.
With BIN Sponsorships and card issuing platforms, fintechs can easily issue cards without going through the process of becoming a bank. Starting a bank can take more than a year and require permission from regulatory authorities to get off the ground; on the other hand, obtaining a BIN sponsorship usually takes around 6 months.
Unfortunately, this is where the assessment becomes more difficult. Merchants that have come to expect a certain level of performance from all cards now must grapple with the fact that a growing minority of their customers are insistent on using these non-standard card products - knowingly or otherwise.
Non-standard card products come with non-standard performance and, often, 8-digit BINs. The combination of elusively sitting behind a Sponsor Bank, carrying typically higher interchange, and having features that break traditional payment flows all amounts to a big problem for merchant payments teams: see the section below for merchant painpoints as it relates to accepting and identifying these BINs.
When you take these factors into account, merchants will have difficulty treating these cards as traditional payment cards, but likely need to view them as distinct alternative payment methods (e.g., PayPal, Alipay, ACH).
BINs by the Numbers
The following data is from a recent CMSPI analysis on BIN trends across its Merchant Payments Intelligence (MPI).
CMSPI found that BINs of Interest generate 65 basis points in higher interchange costs than standard cards while delivering only 12-22% authorization rates on merchant-initiated transactions, creating a double impact on merchant performance.
Merchant debit costs increase on average by 1.6-1.8% per month when BIN tables become outdated, creating almost 5% cost drift within a single quarter if BIN intelligence is not refreshed.
Network token BINs experience approximately 3.5% monthly change rates, more than double the 1.5% seen in PIN debit BINs, making them one of the fastest-moving parts of the payments ecosystem.
CMSPI identified that 5.63% of transaction volume now sits within "BINs of Interest" such as BNPL, fintech, wallet and virtual card programs, making them too significant for merchants to ignore.
13.1% of BINs reveal additional network availability only at the 8-digit level, meaning merchants relying on six-digit BIN logic may be missing routing options and potential savings.
When CMSPI tested 1,000 BINs against a popular commercial BIN database, 555 returned incorrect or missing information, highlighting the limitations of traditional BIN data sources.

0.65%
CMSPI found that BINs of Interest generate 0.65% higher interchange costs than standard cards while delivering only 12-22% authorization rates on merchant-initiated transactions, creating a double impact on merchant performance.

1.6-1.8%
Merchant debit costs increase on average by 1.6-1.8% per month when BIN tables become outdated, creating almost 5% cost drift within a single quarter if BIN intelligence is not refreshed.

3.5%
Network token BINs experience approximately 3.5% monthly change rates, more than double the 1.5% seen in PIN debit BINs, making them one of the fastest-moving parts of the payments ecosystem.

Over 5%
CMSPI identified that 5.63% of transaction volume now sits within "BINs of Interest" such as BNPL, fintech, wallet and virtual card programs, making them too significant for merchants to ignore.

13.1%
13.1% of BINs reveal additional network availability only at the 8-digit level, meaning merchants relying on six-digit BIN logic may be missing routing options and potential savings.

555/1000
When CMSPI tested 1,000 BINs against a popular commercial BIN database, 555 returned incorrect or missing information, highlighting the limitations of traditional BIN data sources.
Data as a Solution
The solution is relatively straightforward, as far as payments go, namely flagging these non-standard products as such in publicly available BIN databases.
Providing merchants with access to these features in advance would certainly help them in being able to process them correctly and without errors, ultimately providing more transparency for merchants and better customer experiences for cardholders.
What About These 11-Digit BINs?
The days of 6-digit BINs are far behind us. The influx of disposable virtual cards and APM-type card transactions is pushing issuers to the limit – all the way to 11-digit BINs. The last four digits are needed to make a transaction unique, but with the PAN only being 16-digits long, only 1 digit is left to the imagination for fraudsters. The longer the BIN, the more PCI compliance becomes a concern.
A Global Perspective
Click the regions below to read more.

APAC

Europe
What Should Merchants Do Now?
The key item for merchants is to expand routing capability - across processors, networks and overall retry strategies - beyond 6-digit BINs. Anything less is causing the erosion of value.
ISO 8583 Connection
DE 2: PAN
The second data element (DE2) of ISO 8583 is the Primary Account Number (PAN). The PAN includes Bank Identification Number (BIN) data which of late has been a topic of interest for merchants, specifically those seeking routing opportunities.
In cases of a Device PAN being used or the general use of tokens, the incognito PAN (dPAN, mPAN, token, etc.) would be located in this data element in place of the actual PAN.
Get Involved
Change only happens when people act. CMSPI and the MPL Council are working together to provide practical solutions to move the payments industry forward. Join one of our working groups to be a part of the conversation.
Working Group Interest Form
Loading...